RealityRewi.red

The NYPD taught a face-search trick its own rules ban. The slides were still on file

New York's police watchdog found a training deck on swapping suspects' photos for pictures of high-profile people, a third of intelligence searches with no supervisor check, and investigators never trained on the software.

Reality Admin//Nov 17, 2026//4 MIN READ
The NYPD taught a face-search trick its own rules ban. The slides were still on file

Somewhere in the NYPD's files there is a PowerPoint deck dated 2024. Detectives in the Facial Identification Section built it for the department's Criminal Investigation Course, the class that teaches detectives what the face-matching unit can do for them. According to a report released Tuesday by New York City's Department of Investigation, the deck was also meant to be shown to outside police agencies to demonstrate what the unit could do.

It taught tricks. It showed how to edit a probe image, the photo of an unknown face that gets fed into the software, when a COVID mask or a bad angle hides the features a match depends on. And according to the department's inspector general for the NYPD, "the presentation also discussed scenarios when investigators substituted publicly available photographs of high-profile individuals for facial recognition analysis in lieu of submitted probe images, in violation of the Policy."

In other words, if a grainy CCTV still looked a bit like someone famous, an investigator could feed the famous person's clean photo into the system and see who came back. The suspect's own face never had to be good enough to match. The report footnotes a 2019 NBC News story on the same habit, headlined "NYPD Used Celebrity Doppelgangers to Fudge Facial Recognition Results."

The NYPD told the inspector general that these techniques were never common practice, that they stopped in 2022, and that the deck was last shown to a class that year. The 2024 date has an explanation too. According to the report, the department kept a copy, "periodically updated (including in 2024), renamed accordingly, and kept available for future use." Auditors went through every policy, memo and operations order the NYPD handed over and found nothing from 2022 onward telling investigators to stop.

A third of searches with no supervisor check

The deck is the vivid part of a long audit. The rest is drier, and if your face ever ends up in one of these searches it is more worrying. The report is the fourth under the city's Public Oversight of Surveillance Technology (POST) Act, and the inspector general picked facial recognition after the Legal Aid Society wrote in August 2025 asking for an investigation.

Start with scale. The Facial Identification Section ran about 26,000 facial recognition analyses in 2025, according to logs the NYPD provided. The Intelligence Division runs its own searches on top of that. Its log for 2019 to 2023 had no column for supervisory review, so auditors couldn't tell whether anyone checked the results. In its log for 2024 and 2025, about 33 percent of searches were marked "no" for supervisor review. The NYPD told the auditors it reads its own Patrol Guide as requiring that review on every possible match.

The Intelligence Division also worked apart from the Facial Identification Section, with no shared process. DOI says this "created a risk that investigators across multiple units may have independently analyzed the same case without awareness of each other's efforts and produced different results." Two units could look at the same blurry face and come back with two different names.

Nobody taught them the software

The NYPD's published policy says staff are trained in "the proper operation of the technology and associated equipment." The auditors found the only required course is a four-day FBI program. Investigators told them it focused on image comparison, and the NYPD said it included no instruction on running the software. The department uses three products: two from DataWorks Plus and Idemia's FaceExpert. The vendors gave one-time training when the contracts were signed. Anyone who joined either unit after that got no formal training on the tools.

The list goes on. The NYPD logged 98 approved requests to run faces through outside photo databases between October 2023 and October 2025. Every one went to U.S. Customs and Border Protection, and every one was signed off by an assistant commissioner, which the auditors say didn't match the policy in force at the time. The department kept no log of such requests before October 2023 and produced no record of any it turned down. It also has no program to check how its vendors' algorithms perform in federal NIST testing, even though its own policy cites NIST evaluations as evidence of accuracy.

DOI Commissioner Nadia Shihata kept her statement measured: "While surveillance technology can be an important tool relied on by law enforcement, its use must be accompanied by public transparency, policies, and procedures to limit the risk of misuse and protect civil rights." Her office issued 17 recommendations. They include mandatory supervisory and blind peer review for every analysis, training on the actual software, a rule requiring top sign-off before anyone edits a probe image beyond standard limits, and annual audits.

The track record here is mixed. When DOI first looked at NYPD facial recognition in 2022, it made two recommendations: write rules on editing probe images, and audit compliance with the policy. The NYPD rejected both. The City Council then wrote them into law in 2025.

The Legal Aid Society wants the technology banned. "The NYPD's procurement and use of facial recognition technology disregards constitutional protections and creates foreseeable harm," it said in a statement reported by Patch. The audit's own conclusion admits that "the law places very few constraints on how and when the NYPD may use facial recognition technology." That leaves the department's rulebook as the main limit, and this report is 17 ways to tighten a rulebook the NYPD has not always followed.

Sources: NYC Department of Investigation: OIG-NYPD POST Act report on facial recognition, Patch.

// RELATED_SIGNALS

More from the feed